Review
“Provocative … engaging.” –Kirkus February 1, 2006
Review
“Fascinating … engagingly written … and highly accessible. A very impressive accomplishment. — David M. Buss, Ph.D., author of The Evolution of Desire
See all Editorial Reviews
…
Buy The Disposable Male: Sex, Love, and Money–Your World Through Darwin’s Eyes at Amazon
I know this posted didn’t really related to the sex and the city box set, so to further get your head spinning here are some other internet posts regarding people talking about sex and the city:
-
DVD: The Complete Series Box Sets « annie.in.mn – Personally, I think the BEST layout for a complete series was by the Sex and the City box set. Take a look at the image below. The whole thing is created into a spiral booklet that opens easily and can be flipped through to find the …
-
dvd / sex and the city box set custom – title: sex and the city box set custom section: dvd date: aug 4, 2008. parts: dvd / sex and the city box set custom / front.
-
Easy Living Blog: Tales from an Easy Living intern – I am not ashamed to admit that I am a Sex and The City-box-set fanatic. It was nice to read about the actress behind Carrie and of her great ambitions for her perfume brand. I have hugely enjoyed my time at Easy Living. …
-
Nothing To Do With Arbroath: Repentant burglars return stolen haul – They also picked things from the living room, including five Xbox games, but only one of the Xbox controllers, a Tom-Tom and a Sex and the City box set, but left the laptop, TV and an Xbox. Then we noticed the front door unlocked and …
-
Fiat 500C news – Let’s play sardines – 2009 – BBC Top Gear – Yes, the whole package is about as masculine as a Sex and the City box set, but you can’t deny it’s a deeply cute cabrio. If anyone mentions the words ‘Citroen’ and ‘Pluriel’ now, we can’t be held responsible for our actions. …


{ 14 comments… read them below or add one }
I am an assistant professor teaching in a field related, but not directly applicable, to the book, which was brought to my attention by one of my students. I am, however, familiar with much of the science.
I would give this book an A for effort, with an overall grade of B+ (which I guess means 4 stars). The deductions are for the lack of footnotes (the author says above that they’re coming to the book’s web site, but there’s simply too much here that’s controversial to excuse the delay). The book also would have been better if opposing views were featured more often and if the language didn’t occasionally sacrifice precision in favor of style.
That said, The Disposable Male is a very bold and highly-readable book. It may succeed where many others have failed and win the prize for conveying the story of evolution to the general public. It’s been almost 150 years since Darwin’s The Origin of Species was first published, and its implications couldn’t be more relevant. The theory of evolution is still wildly controversial, at least in America, just look at some of our faithful school boards. This is where Gilbert shines. The impact of our ancient past, the crucial role our genes and hormones play, not to mention our biological predispositions, count for a whole lot, says the author, even in the way we live our hectic lives today. Near as I can tell, the underlying science is mostly within mainstream thinking and general references are sprinkled throughout the book. Deploying casual language, humor (sometimes side-splitting) and some vivid metaphors in the service of a very ambitious undertaking, Michael Gilbert lays out the Darwinian version of the creation story, educating readers about many crucial aspects of our modern existence. Placing the evolutionary spotlight he develops on contemporary times yields a diagnosis best summed up in his comment that, despite our social progress, “there are cavemen and cavewomen at the keyboards.”
This ground has been tread by other writers. Men Are from Mars, Women Are from Venus actually uses evolutionary principles but it is several leagues beneath this book. Scholars such as Richard Dawkins, Steven Pinker, and Matt Ridley (as well as Robert Wright) aim their work above the heads of the ordinary American reader. Gilbert, who has a disarmingly casual way of talking about some very controversial things, gets it just about right, I think, even if he cuts the odd corner.
At its heart, The Disposable Male is a credo, a way of looking at life. The problem comes when you attempt to apply the philosophy to individual lives. There he, and the many thinkers in the field of evolutionary psychology, is on less firm ground. He’s almost certainly correct when he argues that we’ve gotten too far away from nature. He also makes a point of saying that there is a great deal of variation within each gender when nature’s laws are viewed in human terms. This can’t be said enough and he probably doesn’t.
Perusing the reviews here confirms my sense that this is a provocative, informative and entertaining book. It will elicit a wide range of genuinely heartfelt but not always sympathetic responses. To my way of thinking, that makes it a pretty good read. Here’s how one thoughtful reviewer puts it below. “If there’s a more accessible, broader, and enjoyable presentation of sociobiology/evolutionary insights, I don’t know it.” Neither do I.
(Quote)
This book lays out a Darwinian view of life that says just about everything I think and feel about women and men, sex and romance and what family life is all about. In the first half the author takes you literally from the Big Bang to today. He lays out the evolutionary point-of-view in a funny and very interesting way, explaining how the original relationship evolved between the sexes. There are many interesting diversions along the way, about everything from how our brains developed, to the role our genes play in our make-up now, to the meaning of our sexual fantasies.
In the second half of the book Gilbert turns to our modern lives. Thats when he analyzes how our lives look when you look at it from this evolutionary position. How the lives of men and women today are in harmony with the past and how our lives now vary from it. This leads in to a lot of common sense ideas but also some controversial issues. In a way, its a conservative book but the more traditional values he puts forth are based on science, not on religion.
Feminists are going to hate this book but, as a woman, I found it very fair. In fact, he’s pretty hard on men and often exalts the feminine values, especially in relationships. The author also makes a point of saying how these classical gender roles based on our natural history do not apply to everyone–that there are big differences among each gender. I highly recommend this book. You may not agree with it as much as I did but you’re definitely in for an entertaining read.
(Quote)
5.0 out of 5 stars
FUNNY, THOUGHT-PROVOKING, A GREAT READ!
This is a witty and informative look at life from the perspective of evolution. It’s loaded with interesting ideas and lots of “ah ha!” moments.
(Quote)
If you placed ten people, male and female, in a room with a copy of this book, a discussion could be started that could probably last for weeks. That is the primary beauty of this work. It is absolutely fascinating! Basically, the premise of this work is that there are boys and there are girls, and, thankfully, they are different. This books covers a wide range of subjects dealing with these differences and their impact on our lives and society. Through the eyes of an evolutionist, and through pure common sense, we find where we came from, where we are and where we might possibly be going in the future. This books is very well written. The author displays great insight and his easy writing style is a pleasure. This is the sort of work that will most assuredly make you think. You need not agree with everything the author says, I certainly did not, and you should probably worry about yourself if you did. On the other hand, what the author does do, is dish you out a very large helping of food for thought. He gives us yet another view to help handle life, which is always a good thing. Much of what the author said, I must admit to have already known, or at least suspected and do indeed agree with. The difference is that Gilbert is able to articulate his thoughts in a way I am unable to do. He has obviously spent a great amount of time in research and has gathered together a great amount of information, made it readable and understandable and in fact, rather enjoyable. I do agree with a couple of the other reviewers here that, personally, I would have appreciated a bit more information on his source documents. On the other hand, upon checking on several of his statements (just to keep him honest), I found not one instance where the author had not done his home work and done it well. Recommend this thoughtful work quite highly. This is certainly one you will want to add to your home library. As a side observation, I should think that an afternoon and evening talking to him on my porch with a jug of coffee would be a hoot.
(Quote)
2.0 out of 5 stars
Warning: Does NOT answer what it says it does…
All this author does is say common sense things everyone knows and then haphazardly tries to relate it to how we were evolved to live.
(Quote)
5.0 out of 5 stars
First Class!
Customer Video Review Length:: 8:10 Mins
(Quote)
2.0 out of 5 stars
It’s as if James Dobson wrote an evolutionary book
Stick with Daniel Dennett, this book, is nothing more than conjecture. Look I love evolutionary theory, I see nothing but beauty coming from an appreciation of human life and…
(Quote)
4.0 out of 5 stars
Interesting
Pair this book with Matt Ripley’s “The Red Queen” for an interesting exploration of the evolutionary structures that reside beneath the visible aspects of economic, social, and…
(Quote)
5.0 out of 5 stars
Well written, thought provoking, insightful, loved it!
Not only did I love reading this book because of it’s common-sense approach to the topic but the background history and illustrative examples used to “set the scene” were…
(Quote)
5.0 out of 5 stars
Thank You For Writing The Disposable Male
As a 37 single male living in Hollywood, CA, your book provided me with an insightful and invaluable perspective into “how come” we men are where we are today without being…
(Quote)
1.0 out of 5 stars
Just one man’s opinion
Not only was this book homophobic, the whole book was fiction strung together with quotes and studies that are not footnoted.
(Quote)
3.0 out of 5 stars
Gender stereotypes recast in scientific jargon
The message of this book is simple: Women should step aside because the fact that they are doing “everything” nowadays (working and supporting families on their own) is leaving…
(Quote)
5.0 out of 5 stars
“If we don’t get better, we’re not going to survive.”
Contrary to the title, men are not disposable. They are an integral part of our biological needs of the highest animals on the food chain.
(Quote)
One last test!
(Quote)